Betfair vs Smarkets - Head to Head
Betfair Exchange
Founded 2000 · Flutter Entertainment
Smarkets
Founded 2010 · Independent
Commission saving - 3% = real money
On $1,000 in annual winnings: Smarkets charges $20; Betfair charges $50. Over a full matched betting year with $10,000 in net exchange profits, the Smarkets saving is $300/year. Over three years: $900. Use Smarkets as your primary exchange.
Use Case Comparison - Who Wins?
Fan Bet Odds maps six common use cases to the best exchange for each:
| Use Case | Best Exchange | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Matched betting (primary exchange) | Smarkets | 2% flat, no premium charges, 60-day commission-free welcome |
| High-stakes trading (£5,000+ bets) | Betfair | Only exchange with enough liquidity to match large orders instantly |
| Automated betting bots / API | Betfair | Full open API with extensive documentation; Smarkets API is limited for new accounts |
| First-time exchange user | Smarkets | Cleaner UI, flat commission, no confusing premium charge threshold |
| Niche markets (lower-league football, politics) | Betfair | Deeper order book on markets outside top-5 leagues and mainstream events |
| Long-term consistent winners | Smarkets | No premium charges ever; Betfair applies premium charges to top 0.5% of winners |
Smarkets wins 4 of 6 use cases. Betfair wins where liquidity and API depth are required.
All 4 Exchanges - Full Comparison
Fan Bet Odds compares all four active UK-licensed exchanges across the key criteria:
| Feature | Betfair Exchange | Smarkets | Matchbook | Betdaq |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commission | 5% (2% basic plan) | 2% flat | 2% (UK/IE), 4% elsewhere | 2% net winnings |
| Liquidity | Highest | Medium | Medium | Lower |
| API | Full open API | Limited (new accounts) | Available | Available |
| Welcome | Welcome bonus varies | 0% commission for 60 days | 0% commission for 110 days | 0% commission for 100 days |
| Premium Chg | Yes - top 0.5% of winners | None | None | None |
| UI | Complex, information-dense | Modern, clean, beginner-friendly | Clean, strong mobile app (4.8★) | Familiar Betfair-style layout |
| Markets | Widest - includes niche sports, politics, entertainment | Football, horse racing, politics, US sports | Football, horse racing, Bet Builder | Horse racing specialist, EU football |
Fan Bet Odds Verdict: Use Both
The correct answer is not Betfair or Smarkets - it's both. Fan Bet Odds recommends registering with all four exchanges and maintaining funded accounts on Smarkets and Betfair as your core two.
Smarkets as primary
Open Smarkets first. Use it for all standard matched betting lays, qualifying bets, and regular exchange trades. The 2% flat commission maximises long-term profitability.
Betfair as liquidity backup
Open a Betfair account and keep it funded. Use it when Smarkets can't match your stake size, for automated API strategies, or for niche markets Smarkets doesn't cover.
Matchbook for the longest welcome
If you're new and want the longest commission-free period, open Matchbook for the 110-day zero commission welcome. Then migrate to Smarkets for the long term.
Betfair vs Smarkets - FAQ
18+ only. See our disclaimer →